Our free SSL certificates (AutoSSL) are issued automatically, but only for domains that point directly at our server. If your domain runs through Cloudflare's proxy (the orange cloud in Cloudflare's DNS settings), visitors reach Cloudflare's network first, so AutoSSL cannot check and renew the certificate for that domain.
Cloudflare can issue a free certificate for the connection between Cloudflare and our server:
With a valid certificate installed, AutoSSL normally leaves the domain alone. You can see each domain's certificate on the Status tab of SSL/TLS Certificates. If you still get AutoSSL warning emails about the domain, open a support ticket and we will exclude it from AutoSSL.